Could Moshe have benefitted from Speech Therapy? |
|
|
Thursday, 11 January 2024 |
In Parshat Shmot (Shmot 4:10) when
God first chooses Moshe for the job of taking B’nai Yisrael out of Egypt, Moshe
explains: “I am not a man of words- not since yesterday, not since the day
before- not from the time You first spoke to Your servant, for I am ‘kvad peh’ heavy
(slow) of speech and ‘kvad lashon’ heavy (slow) of tongue.”
In Parshat VaEra (Shmot 6:12) when
God asks Moshe to speak to Pharaoh, Moshe answers “B’nai Yisrael have not
listened to me. How will Pharaoh listen? And I am ‘arel sfatayim’ a man of
uncircumcised lips.”
In both instances Moshe is
explaining that he is not able to speak properly.
According to Ibn Ezra, the
definition of ‘arel sfatayim’, uncircumcised lips is the same a ‘kaved’, heavy.
Moshe’s tongue is covered or tied up and therefore it is difficult for him to
speak.
In Yishayahu 6:9-10 we have an
example of ears being heavy and unable to hear:
God said “Go-tell this people: Hear,
you shall hear but not understand, you will see but you will not know. Fatten
the heart of this people; make their ears heavy ‘v’oznav hacbed’; coat their
eyes with plaster, lest they see with their eyes and hear with their ears, and
their hearts understand and they return and are healed.”
In Yirmiyahu 6:10 we see ears being
uncircumcised and unable to hear:
God said “To whom shall I speak and
warn, that they will listen? Behold their ear is uncircumcised (blocked) ‘arela
oznam’ and they are unable to listen! Behold the word of God has become an
object of ridicule to them; they have no desire for it.”
The concept of heavy eyes, meaning
losing eyesight is found in Breisheet 48:10:
Yisrael’s eyes were heavy ‘kavdu’
with age and he could not see…
Moshe’s speech was impaired and
therefore he felt that he wasn’t up for the job.
God answers Moshe (Shmot 4:11): “Who
gave man a mouth, or who makes a person dumb or deaf? Who makes a person see or
makes him blind? It is not I- God?
God obviously knows that Moshe has
speech issues and can work around them.
Rabbeinu Chananel brings the
interpretation of Rabeinu Bechaya: The fact that Moshe mentioned two
deficiencies shows that he was kvad peh- he had difficulty in forming certain
words which are articulated with the teeth as well as kvad lashon- he had
difficult pronouncing certain letters.
Ibn Ezra explains that Moshe was
born with kvad peh, slowness of speech, he had a problem with labials, as well
as kvad lashon, slowness of tongue which is a problem with linguals. In other
words, it was difficult for him to enunciate some of the letters. God’s
solution was to make sure that the words that Moshe needed to say would not
have the letters that were difficult for him to pronounce.
In response, we see in the next
verse (Shmot 6:13) “God then spoke to Moshe and Aharon, commanding them
regarding B’nai Yisrael and Pharaoh, king of Egypt, to bring out B’nai Yisrael
from the land of Egypt.”
Chizkuni points out that here God is
telling Moshe that he doesn’t have to worry, his brother Aharon would be there
to help him.
This is clear in Shmot 7:1-2:
God said to Moshe, “See, I have made
you a master over Pharaoh, and Aaron your brother shall be your spokesman. You
shall speak everything that I command you, and Aharon, your brother shall speak
to Pharaoh, that he should send B’nai Yisrael from his land.”
Although there was no speech therapy
in those days, Moshe was still able to do the job, despite his limitations.
In the end, begrudgingly, Pharaoh
let B’nai Yisrael go.
No matter what communication issues
or limitations we may have, we must continue to cry out and insist that the
hostages in Gaza are set free. |
The pest that has not left |
|
|
Monday, 16 January 2023 |
In Parshat VaEra, we read about the
first seven plagues. The third plague (Shmot 8:12-15) especially resonates with
anyone who had an outbreak of lice in their home, school, camp or community:
God said to Moshe, “Say to Aharon,
Extend your rod and strike the dust of the earth; and it will turn into lice
throughout the whole land of Egypt.” They did so. Aharon extended his hand with
his rod and struck the dust of the earth, and there were lice on man and beast.
All the dust of the earth turned into lice throughout the whole land of Egypt.
The sorcerers did likewise with their magic art. They tried to bring forth lice
but they could not, and there were lice on man and beast. The sorcerers said to
Pharaoh, “This is the finger of God;” but Pharaoh’s heart remained hardened and
he did not listen to them, as God had spoken.
How far back do lice go?
The Exodus took place sometime
between 1550-1069 BCE so they were already around at that time.
In 2016, a lice comb made of ivory
was found at Tel Lachish in Israel. Just two months ago, in November 2022 an
inscription was found on the comb which may date it all of the way back to 1700
BCE. The sentence which was written in Cananite script is translated as: “May this
tusk root out the lice of the hair and the beard.”
Many other combs were found in
Israel as well. We learn from here that the lice were not only part of the
plague in Egypt but they have also been in the Land of Israel for thousands of
years. Unfortunately they are still here and parents are still combing them out
of their kids’ hair which is still the most effective method of removing them.
It is interesting that the Cananites
wrote a prayer on the comb about eradicating lice and based on the fact that
they also had them in their beards it seems like they affected the whole
population not just the children who primarily get lice today.
Considering that the comb was ivory
and had words on it, we can assume that it belonged to someone wealthy. The poorer
people used wooden combs which have not stood the test of time. This shows that
the lice touched everyone in all classes.
Not only were lice in the land of
C’naan, they were also in Egypt when the plague was not in place, just on a
much smaller scale. In order to try to avoid lice as much as possible, many
Egyptians shaved their heads or had short hair. Wealthy Egyptians chose to wear
wigs as lice prefer to stay in hair that is attached to the head.
May we figure out a way to eradicate
lice once and for all! |
The difference between frogs and lice |
|
|
Monday, 27 December 2021 |
Sponsored by David Frankel commemorating
the 5th yahrzeit of his mother, Basha bat David z”l According to the Midrash, Shmot Raba
10:7, the dust in Egypt was transformed into lice to punish the Egyptians who
forced B'nai Yisrael to sweep up the dust in the streets and marketplaces.
During the plague of lice, when the Egyptians needed dust, they went to
dig but all that they were able to come up with was lice.
In Shmot 8:12-14, we read about the
plague of lice:
God said to Moshe, “Say to Aharon,
Extend your rod and strike the dust of the earth; and it will turn into lice
throughout the whole land of Egypt.” They did so. Aharon extended his hand with
his rod and struck the dust of the earth, and there were lice on man and beast.
All the dust of the earth turned into lice throughout the whole land of Egypt.
The sorcerers did likewise with their magic art. They tried to bring forth lice
but they could not, and there were lice on man and beast.
The Midrash continues: “The sorcerers
were not able to bring about lice with their magic art”. Rabbi Elazar said: “We
learn from here that the sorcerers were not able to use their demons to create
something that is smaller than a barleycorn.” The rabbis taught: “They wouldn't
even be able to create a giant animal like a camel since a demon can't create
anything, they can only gather animals from far places. Big animals can be
brought over but small creatures such as lice could not be brought over.”
In the first two plagues, blood and
frogs, the sorcerers thought that Aharon was using demons. However, when the
sorcerers couldn't bring about lice from the dust the way that Aharon did, they
acknowledged that Moshe and Aharon's work was the "finger" of God and
we no longer see them trying to copy any of the other plagues.
In Shmot 8:2-3 we read about the plague
of frogs:
Aharon extended his hand over the waters
of Egypt, and the frog emerged and covered the land of Egypt. The sorcerers did
likewise with their magic art, and made the frogs emerge upon the land of
Egypt.
In Shmot Raba 10:4 we see an argument over how the frogs were brought
about:
It was taught: Rabbi Akiva said: “There
was one frog and it produced a swarm of frogs and it filled the land of Egypt
with frogs.” Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah said to Rabbi Akiva: “Akiva, what do you
have to do with Aggadah (legend)? Cease your discourses and focus on Halacha,
the laws of Negaim and Oholot! Rather, what happened was that there was
originally one frog and it croaked and the others came.”
It wasn’t a big deal for the sorcerers
to bring frogs because one frog croaked which brought the others over. However,
the lice were too small to bring their friends and actually had to be created
directly from the dust, a miraculous task that only God could perform. |
Enjoy the good times |
|
|
Wednesday, 13 January 2021 |
In Parshat VaEra (Shmot 6:23), we
are introduced to Elisheva:
“Aharon
took Elisheva, daughter of Aminadav, sister of Nachshon, for a wife and she
gave birth to Nadav, Avihu, Elazar and Itamar.”
We learn in the Talmud, Zvachim 102a
and in the Midrash, Vayikra Rabba 20:2:
Elisheva experienced five joys more
than the other daughters of Israel as she saw six of her relatives crowned on Rosh
Chodesh Nisan, the day that the Mishkan (Tabernacle) was dedicated:
1. Moshe, her brother in law was
crowned as king
2. Nachson, her brother was
inaugurated as the Nasi, the prince of the tribe of Yehuda who brought the
first korban (sacrifice) out of all of the Nesiim (princes). As we read in
Bamidbar 7:12:
“And he that offered his offering
the first day was Nachshon ben Aminadav, from the tribe of Yehuda.”
3. Aharon, her husband was trained
and sanctified to be the Kohen Gadol (High Priest).
4. Nadav and Avihu, her sons became
S’ganei Kehuna, deputy priests.
5. Pinchas, her grandson (Elazar’s
son) was chosen to be the Kohen Mashuach Milchama, the priest who was anointed to
lead the army in war. We read about this role in Dvarim 20:2-4:
And it shall be when you come near
to the battle, that the kohen shall approach and speak to the people, and shall
say to them, Shma Yisrael, Hear O Israel, you draw near today to do battle
against your enemies; let not your hearts faint, fear not, and do not tremble,
nor be terrified because of them; for the Lord your God is He that goes with
you, to fight for you against your enemies, to save you.
Unfortunately, Elisheva’s happiness
was short lived (Vayikra 10:1-2):
And
Nadav and Avihu, the sons of Aharon, took each of them his censer and put fire
in it and put incense on it and offered strange fire before God which he
commanded them not. And a fire went out from God and devoured them and they
died before God.
Sadly, Nadav and Avihu were killed and
Elisheva’s joy turned to mourning.
There is no complete happiness in
this world as it says (Vayikra 16:1-2):
God spoke to Moshe after the death
of Aharon’s two sons, when they came near before God, and died; and God said to
Moshe: Speak to Aharon, your brother- he shall not come at all times into the
Sanctuary, within the Curtain, in front of the Cover that is upon the Ark, so
that he should not die; for in a cloud I will appear upon the Ark-cover.
Even though Nadav and Avihu were
righteous and tried to get close to God, they transgressed and in an instant,
all of the joy turned to mourning.
May we enjoy the good times as we
never know how long they will last. |
The goal is getting back to Israel |
|
|
Tuesday, 21 January 2020 |
In the beginning of Parsha VaEra (Shmot 6:1-3), Elokim, God appears to
Moshe and says: “I am HaShem, the Lord. I revealed Myself to
Avraham, to Yitzchak and to Yaakov as E-l (Almighty) Shaddai, but by My Name
the Lord (HaShem) I did not make myself known to them.”
According to Rashi, God made promises to the forefathers, but they were
not yet fulfilled as the time for their fulfilment had not yet arrived.
Ramban quotes Ibn Ezra who brings the opinion of Shmuel HaNagid that the
word Shadai is from the root Shodded (robber or pirate) meaning that God is the
victor and prevailer over the hosts in heaven.
Ramban explains that Shadai was used in reference to the hidden miracles
that delivered our forefathers from death, kept them alive in the famine and
redeemed them in the wars. The blessings and the curses are all miracles as it
is not in nature that the rains should come in their due season when we worship
God, nor are the skies to be like iron if we plant our fields in the seventh
(Shmita) year and similarly all promises in the Torah. They are miracles where
natural law is overpowered, except that no change in the natural world is
noticeable (as opposed to the miracles done through Moshe which openly changed
nature and were used with God’s name HaShem, the Tetragrammaton).
We see the covenant with our forefathers in verse 4:
“I established My covenant with them, to give them the land of C’naan,
the land of their sojourning where they lived as strangers.”
The first promise was made to Avraham in Breisheet Chapter 17:1-2:
When Avram was ninety-nine years old, HaShem, the Lord appeared to Avram
and said to him “I am E-l Shaddai walk with Me and be tamim (perfect). And I
will make My brit (covenant) between Me and you, all will multiply you
exceedingly.”
In sentences Breisheet 17:4-7, Elokim, God, promises Avram that the
covenant will be that he will become the father of many nations. His name will
be changed to Avraham. The covenant will be with Avraham and his descendants
forever.
The covenant is described in Breisheet 17:8:
I will give to you, and to your descendents after you, the land of your
temporary residence, all the land of C’naan as an eternal possession, and I
will be their Elokim, God.
God then commands Avraham (and his future descendents) to perform the
mitzvah of Brit Milah (circumcision).
The Lord, HaShem then reaffirms his promise to Avraham when he speaks to
Yitzchak in Breisheet 26:2-3:
“The Lord, HaShem appeared to him (Yitzchak) and said: ‘Do not go down
to Egypt. Settle in the land that I will make known to you. Stay temporarily in
this land and I will be with you and bless you, for to you and your descendants
I will give all these lands. I will thus keep the oath that I swore to Avraham,
your father...’”
Before Yitzchak sends Yaakov away to Padan Aram to look for a wife, he
blesses Yaakov using the name E-l Shaddai (Breishhet 28:3-4) “And E-l Shaddai
will bless you and make you fruitful and multiply you that you may be a
multitude of people; and give you the blessing of Avraham, to you, to your seed
with you, that you may inherit the land in which you are a sojourner, and which
God gave to Avraham.”
God’s official promise to Yaakov (Breisheet 35:11-12) comes after he returns
to the land of C’naan with his family and after God changes his name to Yisrael:
God, Elokim said to him: “I am E-l Shaddai. Be fruitful and increase, a
nation and a community of nations will come from you, and kings will come from
your loins. The land that I gave to Avraham and Yitzchak, I will give to you;
and to your offspring after you I will give the land.”
Through hidden miracles, Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov lived in the land,
yet it was not yet theirs. The promise was that their future descendents would
inherit the land after the Egyptian slavery and that is why Avraham bought
Mearat HaMachpela in Hevron, Yitzchak had trouble from his neighbors when he
tried to dig wells and Yaakov bought a plot of land in Shchem.
God recounts all of this history to show Moshe that he is the next link
in the chain and the goal is to get B’nei Yisrael back to the land of C’naan (Israel),
the land that was promised to them. This time, B’nei Yisrael will officially
inherit the land, fulfilling the promises that God made to our forefathers.
The State of Israel today is nothing short of a miracle. On a daily
basis, we are threatened from all sides yet we prevail. We see God’s power as
E-l Shaddai, His Hashgacha, Divine protection constantly watching over us.
The Shin on the mezuzah on our doorposts reminds us that the Almighty,
Shaddai watches over our homes as Shaddai represents the acronym of Shomer D’latot
Yisrael, Guardian of Israel’s doors. May He continue to watch over and protect
our private homes as well as the State of Israel. |
Why Raanan Shaked* is wrong |
|
|
Thursday, 03 January 2019 |
In Memory of
David Margolin z”l on his 36th Yahrzeit I made aliya 14 1/2 years ago with
my husband and two young children. We all read Yediot Aharonot every day. We
are Israelis with citizenship and ID cards just like our third son who was born
in Israel. We speak English at home and Hebrew fluently outside. We left a
house and good jobs in NY to come to Israel for one primary reason.
We came to Israel to fulfill a
promise. That promise was given to Avraham (Breisheet 17: 7-8): “I will sustain
My covenant between Me and you, and between your descendants after you
throughout their generations as an eternal covenant, to be a God to you, and to
your descendents after you. I will give to you, and to your descendents after
you, the land of your temporary residence, all the land of C’naan as an eternal
possession, and I will be God to them.”
This promise was later affirmed to
Yitzchak (Breisheet 26:3): “Live in this land and I will be with you and bless
you, for to you and your descendants I will give all these lands. I will thus
keep the oath that I swore to Avraham, your father. I will make your
descendents as numerous as the stars of the heavens, and I will give your
descendents all these lands. Through your descendants shall be blessed all the
nations of the world.”
Yaakov received the blessing as well
(Breisheet 35:12): “The land that I gave to Avraham and Yitzchak, I will give
to you; and to your offspring after you I will give the land.”
When God appeared to Moshe, He
reminded him of His former promises which had not yet been fulfilled (Shmot
6:4): “I also established My covenant with them, to give them the land of C’naan,
the land of their sojourning where they lived as strangers.”
Finally, God promised to fulfill his
promise (Shmot 6:8): “I will bring you to the land regarding which I raised my
hand in oath that I will give it to Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, and I will
give it to you as an inheritance. I am God.”
We see from these promises that the
Land of Israel is a gift to the entire Jewish people and this is where God
wants us to be. There are no specifications about having to be born in Israel,
having to master the language or having to be in a specific political camp. God
wants you in Israel whether you are a lawyer or whether you serve French fries
at a restaurant.
Raanan Shaked can’t understand this.
Why would a Jew leave New York and take a lower paying or less prestigious job
in Israel? Why would they give up a house and move to an apartment? There must
be something wrong with them. He will never understand us no matter how many
Nefesh B’Nefesh flights he observes and no matter how many olim (immigrants) he
interviews. We are here because this is our homeland.
Those who question olim may not
realize that there are many opportunities in Israel that we would not have had
in the USA. Israel is far ahead in the areas of Torah study and Jewish
education and opportunities for Modern Orthodox Jews to break into fields like
joining the Knesset or teaching Zionism through sports, culture and technology
are a dream come true.
Instead of judging us, native
Israelis should appreciate the contributions that olim are making and realize
that we are not a threat but rather people who want to consciously fulfill a
promise and make the State of Israel a better place.
Raanan Shaked was wrong to judge us.
He owes all olim an apology.
*Raanan Shaked is a journalist for
Yediot Achronot who wrote that olim from the United States are a sub-stream of
lunatic Isra-mericans, who would doubtfully get jobs as waiters. |
The hidden prophecies in the butler’s dream |
|
|
Thursday, 11 January 2018 |
A few weeks ago, in Parshat Vayeshev
(Breisheet 40:11) we read Pharaoh’s butler’s description of his dream which
mentioned Pharaoh’s cup three times: “Pharaoh’s cup was in my hand. I took the
grapes and squeezed them into Pharaoh’s cup. I then placed the cup in Pharaoh’s
hand.”
What is the significance of the cup?
One interpretation, as found in Yishayahu
51:17, is that a cup can be used as a metaphor for punishment:
“Awaken yourself! Awaken yourself!
Arise O Jerusalem, you who have drunk from the hand of God the cup of his fury.
You have drunk from and drained the sediments of the cup of bewilderment.”
In the Talmud, Sotah 9a, Rava asks:
Why are three cups stated regarding Egypt? One that is drank during the days of
Moshe (when the Egyptians were punished at the time of the Exodus), one that is
drank in the days of Pharaoh Necho (who was defeated by Nevuchadnezer the king
of Babylon, mentioned in Yirmiyahu 46) and one that it will drink in the future
with its fellows, in the days of the Mashiach (when the Egyptians along with
the other nations will once again be defeated).
In the Torah reading for Parshat
Vaera we read the story of the Exodus where Moshe and Aaron ask Pharaoh to let
B’nei Yisrael out and are refused over and over again eventually leading to the
redemption of B’nei Yisrael and the downfall of Pharaoh and the Egyptians (the
first part of the butler’s prophecy).
This week’s Haftara from Yechezkel,
speaks about Egypt’s downfall centuries later and next week’s Haftara from
Yirmiyahu continues with the same theme of the Babylonian defeat of Egypt (the
second part of the butler’s prophecy).
The prophecies in Yechezkel and
Yirmiyahu emphasize that unlike Egypt, Israel will endure forever. Those who
relied on Egypt rather than on God saw that they were mistaken.
Rashi comments on the Talmud, Sotah
108a that three of the four cups which we drink at the Passover seder
correspond to the three cups from the butler’s dream, but with a positive spin
(the fourth cup is not unique to the seder night as a cup of wine is usually
part of Birkat HaMazon, Grace After Meals).
According to Rav Yaakov Homnick, the
cups of wine at the seder show that we are now kings in our own right. We are
no longer slaves. When we sit at the seder, we are like Pharaoh with the cup of
majesty being placed in our hands.
Rav Homnick adds that the wine cup which
was placed in the butler’s hands represented the fact that he was once again a
free person as he was released from jail and was restored to his position in
the palace.
At the seder, we too rejoice as free
people, celebrating the past redemptions and the hope that the future
redemption is upon us.
|
Don’t bite the hand that feeds you |
|
|
Friday, 27 January 2017 |
In Parshat Vaera, God requests that
Moshe ask Aharon to perform the first three plagues:
Shmot 7:19, God said to Moshe, “Say
to Aharon, ‘Take your rod and extend your hand over the waters of Egypt- over
the rivers, over their canals, over their lakes, and over every place where
their water is gathered, and it (the water) will become blood.’”
Shmot 8:1, God said to Moshe, “Say
to Aharon, ‘Extend your hand with your rod over the rivers, over the steams and
over the lakes and bring up the frogs upon the land of Egypt.’”
Shmot 8:12, God said to Moshe, “Say
to Aharon, ‘Extend your rod and strike the dust of the earth; and it will turn
into lice throughout the whole land of Egypt.’”
Why was Aharon asked to perform the
plagues of blood, frogs and lice and not Moshe?
In Shmot Raba, Vaera 10:4, Rabbi
Tanchum explains that God told Moshe: “The water that saved you when you were
put in a basket in the Nile will not be whipped by you.”
In Shmor Raba, Vaera 10:7, Rabbi
Tanchum continues: “The dust that protected you when you killed the Egyptian
(when you buried the dead body in the sand so that nobody would know) should
not be whipped by you.
We learn from here the concept of “Hakarat
HaTov”, appreciation for the good that others have done for us, even in the
case of water and sand. How much more so should we appreciate the good deeds that
other human beings do for us every day which should not be taken for granted. |
Did the Egyptians Deserve to be punished by the Plagues? |
|
|
Wednesday, 06 January 2016 |
Sponsored by Barbara BEISS Muskin
in memory of, zecher nismat
SARAH BEISS, SARAH BAT YITZHAK
EISIK If Pharaoh was the one who had the idea to enslave B’nai
Yisrael, then why did the plagues affect all of the Egyptians? Did the
Egyptians deserve a collective punishment?
Shadal (Rabbi Shmuel David Luzatto) explains that the entire
Egyptian nation was responsible for the enslavement of B’nai Yisrael.
When reading Shmot 1:9 we read: “He (Pharaoh) said to his
people: ‘Behold, the people of B’nai Yisrael are becoming too numerous and
strong for us.’” If the Egyptians weren’t evil, they would have tried to calm
Pharaoh down and convince him not to hurt B’nai Yisrael. Instead, they kept
quiet and in sentence 11 they went along with Pharaoh’s plan: “They (the
Egyptians) appointed taskmasters over them (B’nai Yisrael) to afflict them with
their burdens.”
It doesn’t say that Pharaoh himself appointed taskmasters
rather it says that “they”, meaning the Egyptians appointed taskmasters.
In contrast, when the midwives (who according to Josephus
and Abravanel were Egyptian women) were asked to kill the baby boys, they did
not comply. The midwives let the baby boys live yet Pharaoh didn’t punish them.
If the whole nation wouldn’t have gone along with Pharaoh’s plan to afflict
B’nai Yisrael, what could he have done to them?
Shadal concludes that since the Egyptians did not protest
the harsh decrees placed on B’nai Yisrael, they were punished along with
Pharaoh and that is why the plagues affected the entire Egyptian population.
When we see that something wrong is happening, we must
follow in the footsteps of the midwives and stand up for justice. According to
Rabbi Saadya Gaon, the reward that God gave the midwives was that He protected
them. May we too merit God’s protection.
|
Why I Don’t Plan to Return to France |
|
|
Thursday, 15 January 2015 |
As a teenager from New York,
I spent three summers in France
immersed in the Jewish community through a program called The French Jewish
Connection.
My high school math teacher, Mr. Harvey Blech z”l couldn’t understand
why I went to France on
vacation instead of to Israel.
He said that after the Holocaust he could not understand why Jews would want to
go to France.
I tried to explain to him that the best way to learn a language and culture was
through immersion but he was not convinced.
In the summer of 1988, I spent a month in Nice, on the Riviera studying French and living with a Jewish family originally
from Tunisia,
owners of a kosher bakery. I sampled all sorts of Tunisian foods, went to the
beach, the Chagall museum and a perfume factory. On Shabbat I prayed in a
Sephardic synagogue. After class I enjoyed shopping for the latest French
fashions. By the time I returned to New
York I was speaking French fluently.
The summer of 1990 was spent in Paris at a Jewish Community Center called
Centre Rachi. I studied French in the morning, toured Paris
in the afternoons, visited the Chateaux in the Loire
Valley, Giverny- The home of Claude
Monet and Versailles and spent Shabbatot with
the Moroccan community of Paris.
I lived in a dormitory on a street that had an open market in the mornings,
boutiques in the afternoons and nightlife in the evenings. A sobering moment
was a visit to the Veldrome d’Hiver indoor sports stadium in Paris where as part of the Vel d’Hiv roundup
in 1942, 7000 Jews were packed in as they waited shipment to the death camps.
In the summer of 1993 Josh (now my husband) and I led a
group of thirteen teenagers from North America to Paris. In addition to visiting the Louvre and
Disneyland Paris we visited the Consistoire- the Grand Synagogue where the
Rabbinate of Paris is housed.
Everything went smoothly until one Saturday night when we
were attacked on the Metro (Subway) returning from the homes of our Shabbat
hosts.
A group of teenagers noticed that the boys were wearing
kippot under their baseball hats and tzitzit under their shirts. They grabbed
one of the boy’s hats and started throwing it around. As we were about to get
off of the train they tried to push one of the boys between the doors of the
train as they were about to close. Josh helped free the boy who was stuck just
in time but not before the teenagers smashed Josh’s head into the wall.
Luckily we all made it out of the train but at that moment
we were all shaken up.
After that incident I thought about Mr. Blech and understood
why he was not interested in going to France.
When the summer came to an end, Josh and I made a decision
not to return to France.
Twenty-two years later things have not gotten better in France, they
have gotten worse.
Were all of those years of studying French wasted now that I
would no longer be going back to France?
I now live in Jerusalem and I
still use my French when speaking to senior citizens who attend my classes in Jerusalem’s nursing
homes. Even though they understand Hebrew, those who made aliya from French
speaking countries when they were already older can often express themselves
better in French and much of their wisdom would get lost in translation.
The younger immigrants from France are anxious to integrate
into Israeli society and are very quick to pick up Hebrew. Over the last few years
we have seen many Jews from France
buy apartments in Israel,
some making aliya. There are many more French students in our children’s
schools in Jerusalem
now than there were ten years ago.
Although I don’t plan to return to France, I now have French neighbors who are just
as warm as the members of the Jewish community that I spent time with while
visiting France.
In addition to coming with a sense of style and culture, the
French Jews who are making aliya are bringing values that Israel
desperately needs: a commitment to Judaism, to Zionism and to religious
tradition.
French immigrants are also contributing to Israeli society.
One example is Golan of Golan Telecom who started a cell phone company which
offers low rates and has helped lower the rates of his competitors.
In Parshat Vaera (Shmot 6:6-8) God promises to bring the
Jews out of Egypt, save them, redeem them, take them as a people and bring them
to the Land of Israel.
May God continue to help the Jews of France and Jews from
throughout the world fulfill the prophecy of making aliya to the State of
Israel. |
Where was Yocheved Buried? |
|
|
Saturday, 28 December 2013 |
In Parshat VaEra, we read about the genealogy of the tribe
of Levi.
In Shmot 6:11 we read: “Amram took his aunt Yocheved for his
wife and she gave birth to Aharon and Moshe. The years of Amram’s life were 137
years.”
Rashi explains the word aunt to mean “Amram’s father’s
sister” since she was Levi’s daughter, Kehat’s sister.
In Bamidbar 26:59 the Torah states that Miriam was
Yocheved’s daughter: “The name of Amram’s wife was Yocheved, daughter of Levi
whom (her mother) bore to Levi in Egypt. She bore to Amram: Aharon,
Moshe and their sister Miriam.”
Rashi states that Yocheved was born in Egypt but she was not conceived in Egypt. As they
entered the walls of Egypt,
she bore her and completed the number of the 70 children of Israel who went down to Egypt (even though only 69 people were listed in
the Torah as going down to Egypt).
In Otzar HaMidrashim, Yocheved is listed as one of the 23
most righteous women of Israel.
The list includes Sara, Rivka, Rachel, Leah, Yocheved, Miriam, the five
daughters of Zelophchad, Devora, the wife of Manoach (Shimshon’s mother), Chana
and Avigail.
There is a tradition that Yocheved is buried in Tveriya
(Tiberius) in a “Tomb of the Mothers” along with Tzipora (Moshe’s wife),
Elisheva (Aharon’s wife), Bilha and Zilpa (Yaakov’s wives) and Aviagil (wife of
King David). They are thought to be buried in the Kiryat Shmuel neighborhood of
Tveriya.
Since we don’t have any evidence to the fact that they are
for sure buried there, it could be that these graves were set up as a place for
women to pray but are not where they were actually buried. Many women go to
Tveriya to pray at their graves for fertility.
After all, it would make sense that Bilha, Zilpa and Avigail
would be buried in the Land
of Israel as they were
living there but what about Yocheved, Tzipora and Elisheva? We don’t have any
concrete information about whether they came in to the Land of Israel.
The fact that a grave was set up to honor these women
(whether or not they are really buried there) shows how much they were looked
up to by the entire Jewish nation.
|
Why is Yichus so Important? |
|
|
Friday, 11 January 2013 |
In Parshat VaEra, Shmot 6:23 we read: “Aharon took Elisheva,
daughter of Aminadav, sister of Nachshon, for a wife and she gave birth to
Nadav, Avihu, Elazar and Itamar.”
Why does the Torah bring us so much background information
about Elisheva, listing who her father and brother were?
According to Eben Ezra, the Torah specifically mentions that
she is the sister of Nachshon to teach us about the secret of the Kehuna
(priesthood). The children of Aharon had special “yichus”, in other words they
came form a good family, from their mother’s side as well, since Elisheva was
the sister of Nachshon the son of Aminadav, the nasi (prince) of the tribe of
Yehuda.
Ramban says that Elisheva, the mother of the Kehuna is the
sister of the most important nasi.
Sforno says that Nachson was the most important nasi of his
generation and Elishava was the mother of important people who would later
become the Kohanim.
A lot of people feel that when choosing a spouse their
yichus is important.
It says in Masechet Yoma 85a: Rabbi Yochanan said: “Whoever
is a Talmid Chaham and his son is a Talmid Chacham and his grandson is a Talmid
Chacham, the Torah will never stop from his descendents.”
The problem is that we can’t only rely on yichus. A person
can have wonderful ancestors, but they must continue to follow in their
footsteps.
Unfortunately, two of Aharon’s sons, did not follow in
Aharon and Elisheva’s footsteps and were put to death by God. As it says in
Vayikra 10:1-2: “And Nadav and Avihu, the sons of Aharon, took each of them his
censer and put fire in it and put incense on it and offered strange fire before
God which he commanded them not. And a fire went out from God and devoured them
and they died before God.”
We read in Midrash Raba 20:10: “Rabbi Levi said: Nadav and
Avihu were conceited. Many women wanted to marry them but they said: Our uncle
is King (Moshe), our other uncle is head of a tribe (Nachshon), our father
(Aharon) is the Kohen Gadol (High Priest) and we are his two assistants. Who
could possibly be worthy enough to marry us?”
We learn from here that our yichus is only as good as the
effort that we put in to cultivate the next generation.
|
Pharaoh the Crocodile |
|
|
Friday, 20 January 2012 |
In Parshat Shmot we read about when God appears to Moshe at
the burning bush. Moshe asks God how the Jewish people will believe that he was
sent by God. God tells him (Shmot 4:3) “Throw it (the rod) on the ground. He
threw it on the ground and it turned into a nachash (snake)…”
In our Parsha, Vaera (Shmot 7:9) God told Moshe and Aharon:
“When Pharaoh speaks to you, saying, ‘Give yourselves [credibility by
displaying] a marvel; you should then say to Aharon, ‘Take your rod and throw
it down before Pharaoh. It will become a tanin (dragon or crocodile).”
Why was Pharoah given the sign of the tanin while Moshe was
given the sign of the nachash?
According to Cassuto: Instead of the nachash (snake), most
appropriate to desert, in which form the sign was transmitted to Moshe, comes
here the tanin (dragon or crocodile), most appropriate to the Egyptian milieu.
The Midrash, Torah Shlema by Rav Kasher explains that there
is a deeper meaning:
God said: This villain boasts and calls himself a tanin as
it says in Yechezkel 29:3 “Thus says God; behold, I am against you, Pharaoh,
King of Egypt, the great tanim that couches in the midst of his rivers (the
Nile and its canals) who has said, My Nile river is my own, and I have made it
for myself.” Go tell him: See this staff, it is a piece of dry wood; it will
become a tanin with life and soul and swallow up the other staffs and it is
destined to revert to a dry piece of wood. You, Pharaoh, likewise, I created
from a putrid drop and gave you empire and you boasted and said “My Nile river is my own, and I have made it for myself.”
Behold I shall turn you back to nothingness and chaos.
Unfortunately, Pharaoh looked at himself as a God and didn’t
learn from the message that was hinted to. Pharaoh remained haughty and his
downfall eventually did come.
The lesson that can be learned here is that no matter how
much we may have accomplished we must not be haughty because at the end of the
day, everything that we have comes from God and everything is in God’s hands.
|
God is Working Behind the Scenes |
|
|
Thursday, 30 December 2010 |
In Parshat Vaera, we see that Pharaoh’s sorcerers through their incantations were able to duplicate the staff turning into a snake as well as the plagues of blood and frogs.
When it came to the third plague, the sorcerers were not able to produce the lice. At that point (Shmot 8:15) the sorcerers said to Pharaoh, “Etzba Elohim Hi- It is the finger of God!”
Even though the sorcerers were not able to conjure up the lice they were careful to only say that it is the “finger of God” as opposed to the “Hand of God.”
Ramban points out that they did not use the name “Hashem”, meaning God of Israel but rather “Elohim”, a generic term for God, making it sound more like a natural phenomenon and less like the God of the Jewish people performing miracles in order to save them.
The fact that the sorcerers were not able to remove the first two plagues and were not able to produce any of the other plagues points to the fact that God was in control.
You can look at the plagues and say that they were just coincidences, natural disasters that have been known to occur in Egypt throughout the ages. However, the bottom line is that the fact that they happened when they did and were stopped only when God wanted to stop them shows that it was not a coincidence.
When looking around at the modern State of Israel as well, we see many things that could be looked at as standard yet when we take a closer look it is clear that there are miracles taking place here all of the time. The fact that many terrorists are stopped before carrying out an attack is just one example.
Let’s keep our eyes open in order to find the hidden miracles that take place each day. |
The Frogs Sanctified God’s Name |
|
|
Friday, 15 January 2010 |
“…Behold I shall strike your entire boundary with frogs. The river shall swarm with frogs and they shall ascend and come into your palace and your bedroom and your bed and into the house of your servants and of your people and into your ovens and into your kneading bowls. And into you and your people and all your servants will the frogs ascend.”(Shmot 7:27-29)
The Gemara in Pesachim 53b brings the following story:
Todos of Rome asked the following question: What did Chananya, Mishael and Azarya (from the Book of Daniel) see that caused them to deliver themselves to the fiery furnace for the sanctification of God’s name?
Todos answered: They took out for themselves a Kal VaChomer argument concerning themselves from the passage of the frogs (in Sefer Shmot) as follows: Whereas regarding the frogs, which are not commanded in the mitzvah of sanctifying God’s name it is written: “The river shall swarm with frogs, and they shall ascend and come into your palace…and into your ovens and into your kneading bowls” (Shmot 7:28). And when are your kneading bowls found next to an oven? At the time that the oven is hot! The Maharsha teaches that the frogs did a wondrous act of sanctification by jumping into the burning ovens since frogs are water creatures who left their natural environment and entered the exact antithesis, the fire of the ovens. We, who are commanded in the mitzvah of sanctifying God’s name should all the more so be willing to sacrifice our lives for that purpose.
Rabbi Yonatan Aivschitz taught when he was eight years old that we learn from this Gemara that all of the frogs were willing to sacrifice themselves and jump into the ovens and they did not fight over who would get to go in the house and who would get to go in the beds- they all went wherever was necessary in order to sanctify God’s name.
There have been many Jewish people who have sacrificed their lives in order to sanctify God’s name. Isn’t it time that we live our lives in a way that sanctifies God’s name? |
Why Blood? |
|
|
Thursday, 03 January 2008 |
In Shmot Raba 9:8 the following question is asked: “Why were the waters first transformed into blood? The answer: Pharaoh and the Egyptians worshiped the Nile. God said “I will strike first his god and then his nation!” Mishnat R. Eliezer 19 asks the same question, but has a very different answer: God brought upon the Egyptians the plague of blood because they threw the children of the Israelites into the river as it says “every male child shall be cast into the river…” Therefore he punished them through the waters of the Nile. Lekach Tov adds that it is because the Egyptians spilled the blood of the Israelites like water. Nechama Leibowitz points out that while Mishnat R. Eliezer and Lekach Tov interpret the plagues as a punishment, measure for measure, Shmot Raba emphasizes the theological aspect, through the plagues they will begin to recognize the true God. Last Friday, two off duty Israeli soldiers, Ahikam Amihai z’l and David Rubin z’l were killed while hiking near Kiryat Arba. We can’t sit idly by and let this happen. Jewish blood is not cheap! Just as our enemies in Egypt were punished measure for measure, so too should our enemies be punished today. Let’s hope and pray that all of the nations of the world will recognize God as well as value human life. |
The True Redemption |
|
|
Thursday, 18 January 2007 |
In Parshat Vaera (Shmot 6:6-8) God tells Moshe "Say to B.nai Yisrael I am God Vehotzeiti- I will bring you out from under the burdens of Egypt, Vehitzalti- I will save you from their slavery. Vega.alti- I will redeem you with an outstretched arm and with acts of great judgments. Velakachti- I will take you to Myself as a people and I will be your God. You will know that I am your God who is bringing you out from under the burdens of Egypt. Veheveti- I will bring you to the land regarding which I raised my hand in oath that I would give it to Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, and I will give it to you as an inheritance. I am your God." In these three psukim we see five words of redemption- vehotzeiti, vehitzalti, vega.alti, velakachti and veheveti. In the Gemara (Yerushalmi Psachim) Rabbi Yochanan asks: "Why do we drink four cups of wine on Pesach?" The four cups of wine correspond to the four words of redemption vehotzeiti, vehitzalti, vega.alti, velakachti. Why don.t we drink a fifth cup to correspond to the word veheveti? According to Torah Temima, this last promise has not fully been fulfilled. Even though B.nai Yisrael were brought to the land of Israel, they were subsequently exiled and many of the Jewish people still remain in Galut (exile). Another idea is that the exodus from Egypt was certain- God took care of everything while the settling and building up of Israel is up to us and has not yet been completed. At the Pesach seder, we pour a fifth cup of wine, the cup of Eliyahu, which we don.t drink, to symbolize the fact that we hope that the full promise of redemption will be fulfilled and that all of the Jews will return to Israel. We pray that speedily Eliyahu will come and at that time the full redemption will take place. |
Don't Take Israel for Granted |
|
|
Tuesday, 24 January 2006 |
In the beginning of Parshat VaEra, God appears to Moshe and reestablishes the covenant that He made with Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov. The Land of Israel will be given to the Jewish people. God is now ready to take B'nei Yisrael out of slavery and bring them to the Land of Israel. In Shmot 6:8 we read "And I will bring you to the land regarding which I raised my hand in oath and I will give it to you as an inheritance (morasha), I am God." According to the Maharam (Rabbi Meir b. Baruch of Rotenberg), there is only one other time that the word morasha is used in the Torah. The word morasha appears in Parshat VeZot HaBracha, Devarim 33:4, "Torah Tziva Lanu Moshe, Morasha Kehillat Yaakov", The Torah which Moshe commanded us is the heritage of the congregation of Yaakov. Maharam explains that the Torah is not an inheritance that easily comes to each person. Rather, we must work hard studying the Torah day and night and constantly be involved in it. As it says in Pirkei Avot 2:12, "Make your self fit for the study of Torah, for it is not yours by inheritance." The Torah does not pass genetically from parent to child and no one acquires it without the necessary mental exertion. The same can be said for the Land of Israel. In order to inherit the land we have to constantly be working for it. We can't rely on God's covenant to our forefathers. After the destruction of the first Beit HaMikdash, we read in the Book of Yechezkel 33:23 "The word of God came to Yechezkel saying: They that inhabit those waste places in the land of Israel speak saying: Avraham was one man and yet he inherited the land, the land is given to us for inheritance (morasha)." God tells Yechezkel to respond: "You eat with the blood and lift your eyes toward your idols and shed blood and shall you possess the land? You stand upon your sword, you carry out disgusting deeds. and you shall possess the land?I shall make the land most desolate and the pride of her strength shall cease and the mountains of Yisrael will be blighted so that none shall pass through. Then shall they know that I am God when I have made the land a total blight because of the disgusting deeds that they have committed." Throughout the Torah and Jewish history we have seen that God is only going to give the Jews the privilege of being able to live in Israel if we earn it. How do we earn the privilege of living in the Land of Israel? By observing the mitzvoth between a person and God By observing the mitzvoth between a person and their fellow person We also have to protect the land on a practical level with a strong army and tight security. Those who are not living in Israel must do what they can to help Israel's economy, social service institutions and educational programs. Each time that I pass a park in Jerusalem I am touched to see the sign that a family from overseas cared enough to help provide a beautiful and safe place for our children to play. Let's continue our efforts to tirelessly study Torah and do all that we can to preserve and beautify the land of Israel which should never be taken for granted. |
|