Is God mentioned in the Megillat HaAtzmaut? |
Sponsored by Vicky Wu, In loving memory of J.J. Greenberg for his love for Israel and the Jewish People. May his memories inspire and strengthen the unity among his beloved People The Megillat HaAtzmaut, Israel’s Declaration of Independence has become very
popular in Israel lately. It was read by many communities on Yom HaAtzmaut
(Israel’s Independence Day) this year and even distributed free in the
newspaper. Some believe that the recipe for Israel’s democracy can be found
there. The Megillat HaAtzmaut was not an easy document for Prime Minister David
Ben Gurion to put together in 1948 as not everyone agreed on the content and it
was especially difficult to get both religious and secular leaders to approve
it. One area that was specifically challenging was whether or not to include
God’s name at the end of the document, right before the signatures. The
religious leaders, Haim-Moshe Shapira and Rabbi Yehuda Leib Maimon wanted God’s
name included, while Aharon Zisling of the secular Mapam party opposed it. In the end, a compromise was made. The phrase “Tzur Yisrael”, “Rock of Israel” was used: “Placing our trust in
the Rock of Israel, we affix our signatures to this proclamation…” Does “Tzur Yisrael” refer to God?
Where have we heard these words before? The word “Tzur” is found seven times
in Parshat HaAzinu (Dvarim 32): Verse 4: “The Rock! Perfect is His
work, for all His paths are justice.” Verse 15: “…And it was contemptuous of
the Rock of its salvation.” Verse 18: “You ignored the Rock who
gave birth to you…” Verse 30: “…If not that their Rock
had sold them out…” Verse 31: “For not like our Rock is
their rock…” Verse 37: “He will say, ‘Where is
their god, the rock in whom they sought refuge.” Rambam explains in Moreh Nevuchim (Guide for the
Perplexed) 1:16: The Almighty is called “Rock” as God is the origin and
the efficient cause for all things besides Himself…Be firm and steadfast in the
conviction that God is the source of all things, for this will lead you towards
the knowledge of the Divine Being. In King David’s final speech (Shmuel II: 23:3) we find
the phrase “Tzur Yisrael”: The God of Israel had declared: The Rock of Israel has
said to me: He who rules men justly, he who rules in awe of God… We also find “Tzur Yisrael” in Yishayahu 30:29 in a
depiction of what the End of Days will look like: The song will be yours like the night of the festival’s
consecration, and heartfelt gladness like one who walks with a flute, to come
onto the mountain of God, to the Rock of Israel. And of course, every morning we say “Tzur Yisrael” right
before reciting the Amida prayer where we pray for the liberation that is yet
to come: Rock of Israel, arise to the aid of Israel and liberate
as you pledged, Yehuda and Israel. A day before the end of the British Mandate, David Ben
Gurion said to Rabbi Yehuda Leib Maimon and to Aharon Zisling: Each of us believes in “Tzur Yisrael” as he understands
it. For you, HaRav Maimon, it is the God of Israel. And for you, Mr. Zisling,
it is the might of our people. Ben Gurion did not put it up for a vote knowing that it
was still going to be opposed by Zisling and that is how they were finally able
to move on to complete the document. We learn from here the importance of trying to work out
compromises which everyone can live with, even if they may not be agreed upon
by everyone, in order to work towards a common goal. We also see how important it
is to go back to our roots in the Tanach which the foundations of the Megillat
HaAtzmaut are based on. |