Sometimes it is necessary to leave Israel |
In Parshat Miketz (Breisheet 42:5-9)
we read: B’nai Yisrael came to buy among the
others who came, for there was famine in the Land of C’naan. Yosef was the
ruler over the land; he was the one who sold to all the people of the land.
Yosef’s brothers came and prostrated themselves to him with their faces to the
ground. Yosef saw his brothers and he recognized them, but he acted like a
stranger to them. He spoke harshly to them and said to them, “Where did you
come from?” They said, “From the land of C’naan to buy food.” Yosef recognized
his brothers, but they did not recognize him. And Yosef remembered the dreams
which he had dreamed about them, and he said to them, “You are spies.” “You have come to see where the land is
exposed.” Why did the brothers add that they
were there to buy food? The ruler didn’t ask why they came, only where they
came from. It was pretty obvious why they were there as everyone who came to
Egypt at that time was looking for food. One reason could be that the
brothers felt guilty for leaving home, even for a short period of time since
leaving the Land of C’naan was a big deal in those days especially since the
forefathers only left when it was absolutely necessary. Why did Yosef accuse them of being spies? The fact that they gave more of an explanation than necessary could lead
one to believe that they were making up a story. Yosef used this to his
advantage as Kli Yakar points out: Yosef was worried that now that the brothers
were in Egypt, they would start looking for him as they knew that he was sold
to Egypt. Yosef didn’t want to take a chance where they would start asking
around and end up finding out who he really was, therefore he accused them of
being spies to make sure that they wouldn’t talk to anyone. Did the brothers really want to find Yosef? We will never know for sure.
They were embarrassed about what happened and would probably have preferred to
stay in C’naan rather than having to face him again. However, in the end it
worked out for the best because the brothers had an opportunity to do Tshuva
(repent), Yosef was able to accept their apology and explain that it was all
part of God’s plan and Yaakov was able to be reunited with his long lost son. Even though it is best to stay in the Land of Israel, sometimes it is
necessary to leave such as in the case of a famine where there is really
nothing to eat. May we be blessed with prosperity in the Land of Israel so that nobody
will have to be forced to leave because they don’t have enough food. |