Can you be both an alien and a resident? |
After Sarah’s death, when Avraham
goes to buy a burial plot in Chevron, he tells the sons of Chet (Breisheet
23:4): “I am a foreigner (ger) and a resident (toshav) among you.” Rabbi J. David Bleich points out that
the biblical commentators struggle with this contradiction. If one is a toshav,
then they are not a ger. If one is a ger, then they are not a toshav. If a
person is a stranger, they are not a permanent resident; if a person enjoys
rights of residency, they are not an alien. One may be a citizen or a
foreigner, a national or a stranger, but a person can’t be both at the same
time. Rabbi Bleich explains that a Jew of
today who has visited Chevron knows exactly what Avraham meant. A Jew visiting
Chevron today knows what it means to be a ger and a toshav. A Jew feels at home
in Israel but in Chevron, one experiences another emotion as well. In Chevron,
particularly at Maarat HaMachpela (The Cave of the Patriarchs and Matriarchs),
one has a strange feeling, “Here I am; these are our holy places. And yet I am
told when I may enter and when I may not enter, where I may pray and where I
may not pray. One experiences the dichotomy existentially: “This is mine. Yet
if it is mine, why do I feel as a ger? Why do I feel like a stranger?” There is
a tension in the air. I completely understand what Rabbi
Bleich is talking about and I have felt that way every time that I have been to
Chevron considering how many soldiers need to protect us while we are praying
there. Rabbi Shmuel Mohilever observed: In purchasing this parcel of land,
Avraham paid more than the fair market value. According to the rabbis, the land
was not worth the 400 silver shekels which Avraham paid. So why does the Torah
record the exact purchase price? Rabbi Shmuel Mohilever remarked: The Torah here teaches us a lesson
of great significance. The Torah emphasizes that there is no price that is too
high for even the smallest portion of the Land of Israel. I agree with Rabbi Mohilever and
part of the Mitzvah of Yishuv Eretz Yisrael, Settling the Land is buying
property. However, in many areas of Israel today the cost to buy or rent an
apartment is prohibitive. When you look at the population of
Kiryat Arba (the Jewish neighborhood next to Chevron) today, you will notice
that there are many new immigrants from different countries including the
former Soviet Union, the United States and India who may not be living there
for ideological reasons but rather moved there because the prices were
affordable. May we all merit to own a piece of
the land of Israel. |