What is the big deal about moving boundaries? |
Sponsored by the Halickman family in honor of the upcoming wedding of Rivi Weisman and Alec Kholodenko In Parshat Shoftim (Dvarim 19:14) we
read: “Do not move a boundary of your neighbor, which the early ones marked out
in your inheritance, which you shall
inherit in the Land that HaShem, your God gives you to possess it.” Why do we need to be told “Lo tasig
gvul re’echa”, “Do not move a boundary”- Isn’t it obvious that by moving our
boundary we would be stealing land from the neighbor’s property? Shouldn’t that
already be covered in “Lo Tigzol”, “Do not steal” (Vaikra 19:13)? Rashi explains that a person who
overturns his neighbor’s boundary violates both of these negative commandments. Does this also apply outside of the
Land of Israel? Rashi states that if you overturn
your neighbor’s boundary in the Land of Israel then you violate two
commandments. But outside of Israel, you only violate the commandment of “Do
not steal.” According to Ramban, this verse is a
warning against changing the boundaries of the division by which the nesiim
(princes) appointed the Land to the tribes or to any individual among them. Therefore,
he mentioned the “early ones” (Yehoshua, Eleazar and the tribal leaders) and
mentioned “in your inheritance, which you shall inherit…” The reason for this
commandment is that no one should contemplate to say, “My portion which they
gave me is not as valuable as the portion on my friend, because the dividers
erred,” or he may feel suspicious of the lots, thus he will not consider the
removal of the boundary marker to be robbery at all. Therefore it is commanded
here that no one should controvert that division and he may not make any change
in the boundaries, either secretly or openly. Ibn Ezra adds that although moving
boundaries may not sound like such a big deal, it can lead to arguments,
fighting and even murder. We see that by moving boundaries,
one violates two commandments and may even be endanger their life. Do we need
any more proof that it should not be done? |