Don’t shame anyone- even a tree |
In Parshat Ekev (Dvarim 8:8), we are told that the Land of Israel is a
land of the seven species: “A land of
wheat and barley, and grapes and figs and pomegranates; a land of olive oil and
(date) honey.” When Adam and Chava ate from the
Eitz HaDa’at (Tree of Knowldege) did they eat from one of these seven species
and if so, why is the one that they ate not made clear? The incident is found in Breisheet 3:6-7:
“The woman saw that the tree was good for food and that it was tempting to the
eyes and that the tree was appealing as a means of obtaining wisdom. She took
of its fruit and she ate, and she also gave it to her husband and he ate. The
eyes of both of them were opened and they realized that they were naked. They
sewed together fig leaves, and made for themselves loincloths.” Why does the Torah tell us that fig
leaves they used to make clothing? At first glance it would seem that
fig leaves were used since they are very large so they make a good choice for a
cover up. According to Rashi, the Torah
specifies fig leaves since that is the tree from which they ate. Rashi quotes the Talmud, Sanhedrin
70b: “with that which they sinned they set themselves aright.” Why is the name of the tree not specifically
revealed? Rashi explains that this is because
God does not want to grieve any being. He did not want the tree not be shamed
by people saying, “This is the one through which the world was stricken.” We learn from the fig that if we are
not supposed to shame a tree, then we certainly are not supposed to shame a
person. Of course, as the saying goes: two
Jews, three opinions. Not everyone agrees that they ate from the fig tree. In
the Talmud, Brachot 40a, Rabbi Meir says that it was a grapevine, for there is
nothing that brings as much wailing upon man as wine does. Rabbi Yehuda says
that it was a wheat stalk. Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Yehuda may have
brought up these other opinions to take some of the heat off of the fig. In any case, whichever fruit it was,
it was not removed from the list of the seven species of Israel which are
praised and respected throughout the TaNaCh. |