Why should we specifically settle Israel? |
In Parshat Masei (Bamidbar33:53) we
are commanded: “Drive out the inhabitants of the land and settle in it, because
I have given this land to you to possess.” Ramban (Nachmanides) believes that
it is a positive commandment to dwell in the Land of Israel and inherit it. Why?
Because God gave it to them and they should not reject the inheritance of God.
Thus if the thought occurs to them to go and conquer the land of Shinar or the
land of Assyria or any other country and to settle therein, they are thereby
transgressing the commandment of God. Nehama Leibowitz points out that
Ramban’s reasoning does not mention that the obligation to settle the Land is
because it is a good land, better than the desolate lands of the other nations.
Rather, because the Land was given to the Jewish people “and they should not
reject the inheritance of God.” Nehama Leibowitz adds: If you check
Sefer Breisheet, you will not find the good properties of the Land or the
concept of “a land flowing with milk and honey” mentioned at all to our
forefathers. Avraham was not brought to the land to “eat from the fruits and be
satisfied from all of the goodness.” Rather, all three of our forefathers encountered
a famine during the time that they lived in the Land. The Patriarch’s loyalty
to the Land was tested. Avraham left the Land during the famine but learned his
lesson when he went down to Egypt and immediately came back. Yitzchak was not
allowed to leave, even when there was a famine. The reason: “For unto you, and
unto your seed, I will give all these lands.” Nehama Leibowitz continues, God determines
the boundaries of the nations. God allotted Israel its place in the world just the
same as He did for the other nations. However, the Jewish people are aware that
God granted the Land to them. This is not a matter of history but involves a
religious mission, a moral obligation, the responsibility to observe a
particular way of life in the Land. Israel was the Land given to the
Jewish people and we are therefore commanded to settle it. Everything else- the
delicious fruits, the beautiful scenery etc. is a bonus. This is our gift from
God. As the popular song by Ehud Manor goes, “Ein li eretz acheret”, “I have no other land, even if my earth is
burning.” As we have been watching the fields next to the Gaza strip set on
fire by kites from Gaza, that song resonates with us now more than ever. May we
see the end to the fires and return to the days when kites were used for fun
and not for war. |